I'm confused. Bluefrog, are you looking for more clean headroom, or more of the cranked overdrive tone? If you want for overdrive, you could swap to an EL844 power tube. Its super easy and costs ~ $15.00 for the tube shipped.
If you want the C5 clean tone, but louder, then cooler pre-amp tubes might get you there. I get some great jazz tones from my C5 especially with the stock tubes and the volume on about 2 or 3. In about a week or so (I have some recording gear coming in) I'll get to dime my amp with the EL844 powertube and really hear how that sounds